Can you Critique These?

[dfwnoff]

 

[Designer]

Heck yeah! I can critique anything!

You want all four? That will mean my comments will be short and to the main point only.

#1 cropping way too tight, detail lost in shadow, ambiguous mood/pose
#2 cropping way too tight, foreground is distracting
#3 no clear subject, conversion not contributing
#4 cropping way too tight, foreground is distracting

 

[dfwnoff]

Thank you for the comments. I actually didn't crop any of these, should I have stepped back more? But that would have more of the distracting foreground. . .