Canon 70-200mm f/2.8L USM Lens Recommendations

[tommynthompson]

I am planning to purchase a 70-200mm f/2.8L USM IS lens. My question is should I purchase the older version or the newer version. If I purchase the older one, I would have the money remaining to purchase another item such as a flash or extender, etc. Otherwise, the purchase of the newer lens would be that alone. From what I have read, the newer lens is outstanding and worth every penny. Any comments are welcome and thanks in advance.

 

[Ricky21]

I purchased the older version (IS I) about a week ago and the quality is outstanding. I think it comes down to they $$ difference.

 

[tommynthompson]

Thanks for the comment. My mother gave me the money for the newest version for my birthday so it's not a matter of money. I am just curious about anyone's opinions about whether I would be better served to purchase the older version and purchase additional accessories or go for the newer and save for accessories.

 

[penfolderoldo]

Well although I use the non IS version (don't need it, and the extra weight matters when you're lugging it around along with a ton of other gear all day!) I did use the original IS version for a while, and it's a great performer, so I suppose it comes down to what you shoot and whether the extra kit you can get by going for the older version will be more useful to you.

 

[Hardrock]

I've owned both and used on a crop sensor. The mkII is way sharper at f2.8 throughout the zoom range. I was disapointed with the mkI and very very happy with the mkII. I could have had a bad copy on the mkI so you could factor that in but if you have the money I say get the mkII.

 

[tommynthompson]

My main purpose for purchase is to shoot high quality shots of my children during sporting events, both indoor and outdoor, and their other activities. I also like to shoot wildlife and landscapes.

 

[Overread]

My main purpose for purchase is to shoot high quality shots of my children during sporting events, both indoor and outdoor, and their other activities. I also like to shoot wildlife and landscapes.

Get the MII - don't even worry about the MI (its a fantastic lens don't get my wrong, the newer is just better) and then for your next expense get yourself a 2*TC (MII or if you want to splash out the MIII). You'll have a 140-400mm lens from the combo which is pretty much as good as good copy of the 100-400mm L. Ideal for a wildlife shooting lens.
Further with the 2*TC you can get a good close up shot of subjects as well as take the TC off for a 70-200mm that is fantastically sharp and great for landscape work.