CC please, on some cat pictures

[Abby Rose]

yes yes, the dreaded cat pictures. Hopefully they're not too snapshot-ish.

1.


2.


3.


Thanks!

 

[C_mo]

I'm just a noob, so what I post should (obviously) be taken with a grain of salt, but I'll take a stab at commenting

1. is very nice, I really like the DOF and how nicely framed the cat is. It looks a little pissed off, but it adds to the photo I think

2. Cool shot, although some of the cat on the left is blurry. There is a lot of empty space to the left, which takes away from it IMO.

3. I'm just not a fan of the style of this one. Just not my taste.

Good job all around

 

[MissCream]

I like the first one but the last two are out of focus and that's a killer for me.

 

[Aerr]

#1 is the best.

 

[marmots]

#1 is the only one that says anything, though i think the white balance is a little off
#2 would have been ok if 1. you were lower, 2. you were closer, 3. you didn't cut him off, and 4. the cats were actually sharp
#3 just doesn't have anything going for it, it could be good as a novelty image, but nothing more

 

[Abby Rose]

Thanks guys!

Regarding the WB on #1... (marmots) is it too yellow/green tinted? Because looking at it now I think it might be, but I want to know if others see it the same.

#2: I didn't cut him, off, he dived into the plants.

 

[DorkSterr]

I like #1. What I would of done is gotten a closer shot of the cat and eliminated the extra space on the top and bottom of the picture. The leaves on the right hand side is just distracting.

Numbers 2&3 are just...