In a close-in situation like this, with shallow DOF due to ambient light, you have to decide where to put the majority of the DOF...on the girl's face? Or on the pumpkin? In this case, you've got mostly the pumpkin and her hand and the marking pen in focus, and her face is a bit soft--I think that way the RIGHT decision, all the way. She's cute, and as terri mentioned, her being so small in relation to the punkin' does bring a smile!