Clear Creek Falls

[RxForB3]

Part of what I like about #1 (though I'm not sure it's very evident to anyone who didn't see it in person), is the mist on the right side. In the closer shot of #2, you can't see any of it.

 

[Compaq]

Apparently, you were able to move just enough to get that tree out of the way fro #2. You should have taken another shot of the entire scene at that spot.

#1 and 2 are two completely different images, and are meant to convey two completely different feelings. The way I see it: Whereas #1 is a scenic view of the waterfall and surrounding area, #2 is a closeup portrait of a lonely tree... on a cliff... right in front of what seems like an epic waterfall. I don't think you really can compare the two images and decide which are the better one, because they are completely different. I get a sense of pride yet loneliness. Strong and remote. Anyway, it's not perfect, IMO. Some distracting trees in lower part of the frame. I also think the tree should be brighter. And one can always introduce some mist in photoshop (maybe I added too much, but just to demonstrate). I just tried to make it "pop" a bit more.

 

[Joel_W]

I much prefer picture #1 over #2. Compaq's post completely echos my point of view.

 

[Compaq]

Are you sure you got your numbers right, Joel? Or maybe I'm just dumb

 

[Majeed Badizadegan]

I'm confused too

 

[Majeed Badizadegan]

Anders, I think the main thing that bothers about the closer shot is the softness in the trees in the foreground.

 

[Compaq]

Sure, maybe the focus isn't perfect. And that would be a problem for large prints. However, I still prefer the composition. :thumbsup:

 

[HughGuessWho102 17]

#2 gets my vote. The lone tree, in front of the slightly oof waterfalls, makes that shot IMO.

 

[RxForB3]

Well I think I'm about to head out there again. I'll try to retake the first photo from a better spot to get the tree out of the way and get a shot with a slow the shutter speed. Then I'll try to retake the second shot but use my 55-250 kit lens that can be used on my tripod for a sharper picture and a slower shutter speed...

 

[Joel_W]

Are you sure you got your numbers right, Joel? Or maybe I'm just dumb

Sorry if I once again caused some confusion. I was referring to your statement that each picture convey a completely different feeling.

 

[RxForB3]

Thanks to all for the suggestions! I think the reshoot went well. I posted on a new thread and would love any new thoughts and suggestions.

By the way, compaq, I really like the edit you did! Gives it a lot more character.