I would like to see a shot with the column's shadow tone rendered in-between the first one's deep, dark shadow value, and the way the shadows are rendered in the revised version, in which the column shadow's actual tonal value placement is too high on the scale to convey a sense of it being a strong, crisp shadow--it's rendered too "open" a shadow tone, at least for on-screen viewing.
As an aside, if you were printing the file, it would typically require that the shadow tones that look best on-screen be lightened by a print tone curve adjustment operation in software.