Crop or Crap???

[photo gal]

Crop?

No crop???

or crap?????

 

[Wigwam Jones]

I like both photos, cropped and uncropped. The reflection in the glass doesn't work for me - I find it distracting. I'd say a polarizing filter would be in order for this. Take away the reflection, and I'd say cropped is most interesting. Just my 2 cents, I'm no expert.

 

[Arch]

No crop for me all the way..... the image behind adds context to the picture imo.... i like the shot pgirly.

 

[JTHphoto]

No crop for me all the way..... the image behind adds context to the picture imo.... i like the shot pgirly.

my sentiments exactly... :thumbup:

 

[chakalakasp]

Cropped, it's boring. Uncropped, it's brilliant.

 

[GoM]

No crop for me all the way..... the image behind adds context to the picture imo.... i like the shot pgirly.

Much agreed....the only 'improvement' I'd make to it is to get rid of the reflection, if that's at all possible with a window, though you can't really take the same shot twice, so...nice shot

 

[essjayyell]

another vote for uncropped

 

[SeanL]

Looks like someone needs a polarizer or a UV filter.

 

[photo gal]

Thanks for the imput everyone, I appreciate it! : )

 

[Becky]

I think this is a great shot as it is!!!! Not crap in the slightest!!!

 

[LaFoto]

No crap! No crop!
(Who had the cheek to tick on "crap" I wonder?)

 

[Chiller]

Un cropped for me to Photo Girly.

 

[photo gal]

Awwww thanks Becks, Corinna and chilley!! : )

 

[SantosD50]

I like the non cropped. It's stronger!

 

[MightyLeeMoon]

I'll also chime in with No Crop. And second the notion that the reflections cab be a tad distracting.