What's new

Filters

canonbraden

TPF Noob!
Joined
Jan 22, 2013
Messages
183
Reaction score
12
I'm looking to get new filters because I got a new lens. The main question I have is: does it matter if I get screw-in filters or the rectangle filters that go over the lens rather than screw in? Opinions? Thanks in advance
 
CPL and ND filters work fine as screw-in as long as they are not used on a wide angle lens.

GND filters work best as rectangular filters so you can adjust where in the scene the dark part of the graduation is.
 
CPL and ND filters work fine as screw-in as long as they are not used on a wide angle lens.

Why do you say that? I have a 10-24mm and use a CPL all the time and haven't noticed any effects.

Just curious.
 
CPL and ND filters work fine as screw-in as long as they are not used on a wide angle lens.

Why do you say that? I have a 10-24mm and use a CPL all the time and haven't noticed any effects.

Just curious.

Maybe you have a thin-frame CPL filter. I've the same lens and my CPL filter is "normal" thickness, and it does cause a little vignetting.
 
The only thing you need to worry about is the quality of the filter.
 
As ones' lens 'collection' grows, you'll find that no matter what, you'll need different size screw in filters. At one point, I needed 5 different size filters if I wanted to fit each of my 7 lenses. Bulky to carry and devastating to the wallet. So, before I went off the deep end buying filters, I decided to go with one or more 'step up' rings and buy only the largest size filters.

But these days, I have 4 lenses, and, of course, 4 different filter sizes needed! Surprise, surprise! But I decided to 'cheap out' and only buy 77mm filters and step up the 67mm and 72mm sizes. For the 82mm filter size EF 16-35 f2.8L ii...I just have to avoid putting filters on that one. But if I decide to get a GND...I'll go with the larger size square filter and various mount adapter sizes.

The only negative to 'stepping up' and using larger filters is that the lens hood either has to be put on before putting on the stepped up filters, or, the hood won't fit at all. When that happens, I've resorted to using my left hand as a 'hood' (having a handstrap on the camera works wonders). Some have suggested a taped on note card will work, too. All I have to do is remember to bring the card and tape!
 
As ones' lens 'collection' grows, you'll find that no matter what, you'll need different size screw in filters. At one point, I needed 5 different size filters if I wanted to fit each of my 7 lenses. Bulky to carry and devastating to the wallet. So, before I went off the deep end buying filters, I decided to go with one or more 'step up' rings and buy only the largest size filters.

But these days, I have 4 lenses, and, of course, 4 different filter sizes needed! Surprise, surprise! But I decided to 'cheap out' and only buy 77mm filters and step up the 67mm and 72mm sizes. For the 82mm filter size EF 16-35 f2.8L ii...I just have to avoid putting filters on that one. But if I decide to get a GND...I'll go with the larger size square filter and various mount adapter sizes.

The only negative to 'stepping up' and using larger filters is that the lens hood either has to be put on before putting on the stepped up filters, or, the hood won't fit at all. When that happens, I've resorted to using my left hand as a 'hood' (having a handstrap on the camera works wonders). Some have suggested a taped on note card will work, too. All I have to do is remember to bring the card and tape!

Yeah, I was trying to avoid spending $80 more on just a single filter. I found something on amazon that would work! Thanks everyone for the information
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Back
Top Bottom