Also, your listing of data (again, this was EXIF data and not camera settings....) shows "Max sensitivity 6400" which implies to me that ISO is still Auto. The metering system set it to 100 because of the brightness of the subject. Allowing the camera to set ISO WILL take some exposure control away from you.
Also, this may be a difference between the chipped version and the un-chipped version, or a difference between your D3200 and my D7000, but I have to set aperture on the camera, not the lens. I'm pretty sure that's because my Rokinon is chipped, though. I have some older non-electronic lenses that do require the aperture to be set using the lens's ring, which seems to be how you have to use yours. But yeah, the default f:22 is awfully dim for most work!
You're probably also finding that focusing isn't exactly child's play with manual-focus lenses. Modern AF dSLRs don't have tyhe viewfinder aids for manual focusing that older cameras had, like the split-image or micro-prism ring in the center.
Does sound like the shutter is closed all the way. Try taking the lens off and look through the back while you move the shutter lever. The shutter opens for the viewfinder but when you fire the camera releases the shutter and it goes to whatever is set on the lens.
I marked your post "Disagree" because the shutter is not set on the lens, then I realized that you may be speaking of aperture iris and not the shutter. Just explaining the clicking I did....