Foggy autumn road - which one of these three versions?

[Compaq]

If you have to choose, which one? If you could explain, I'd be grateful. Feel free to comment and criticize.

#1

#2

#3

 

[Robin Usagani]

#2


The other the lights look weird.

 

[VanGogh121]

#1.... feels better

 

[markv20]

The lights look odd, almost like they were added in ps although I know they werent. Id be interested to see what these looked like in color. I really like autumn colors so Im not a big fan of removing the colors.

 

[joealcantar]

I'm favoring #3 as it gives you an eire feeling of going into the scene. It is the only shot that the lights have the color hue though.
-
Shoot well and thanks for sharing, Joe

 

[Hickeydog]

#1. The eye is naturally drawn from the bottom left up to the top left, up to the lights. It has a great flow.

 

[Ron Evers]

#1 for me, it has more presence, if that makes any sense.

 

[Compaq]

I was leaning on #1 myself before I posted.
And it sort of makes sense, RE.

 

[Ballistics]

The first 2 are great. Not feeling the 3rd. But the first 2 give such a lonely desolate feel. Reminds me of nights as a kid when I had to ride my bike or walk home in the dark to get home. I love being able to identify with a picture.

 

[Sonoma]

#1, the lights in the background look more mysterious! Nice find!

 

[greenjeans]

#1

 

[photobykelly]

I like #2 best, Nice job

 

[Ballistics]

After looking again, #3 is growing on me. I think the fact that the headlight effect that's going on(whether it be from headlights or not) adds to the picture rather than take away from it.

 

[LizardKing]

1 or 2... You'll probably first need to decide what you want to generate in the viewer... I once read that our eyes and brain are used to "read" the picture from left to right... If that's "correct" or "normal", then the first picture feels like you're coming and the second like your going...

I don't know, just trying to analize a little the lines you have here...

Regards,
LizardKing

 

[rateeg]

2