Two softboxes at equal, 45 degree angles to the baby = dual, competing main lights. That produces the flatness that amolitor referred to, which is most obvious in shot #3. The competing light sources basically cancel one another out, so there is very little shadowing created, and very little shape or sense of depth conveyed. That said, these shots are sort of thematic baby pictures...baby playing "dress-up", as it were. And I think most people would find these cute pictures, just based on subject matter. Subject matter counts a LOT. Posing and props are important too, and the props, and the poses, are cute. So...the lighting being very low-ratio takes a backseat on these, for me. I think this baby's parents and grandparents will absolutely love these. As to the catchlights being "too big"--I think that is debatable. I personally like them big. SOme people do not. Some people even clone catchlights out of the eyes--which seems in my experience to be a big thing, mostly in England, and I have no idea why.