Here is one that I took a while ago and always quite liked though struggled to find the right processing for it.
good
-good off center placement of the dog and building
-good reflection in the window
-exposure is right on
-good DOF
-colors are natural
nit
-to much negative space on the right side of the photo
-stray tree branches on the far right in the sky are a bit of a distraction
-photo is a tad flat (lacks contrast)
-photo is a tad soft
tweak
-cropped a little off the right side of the photo to reduce some negative
space and to get rid of the stray branches on the right in the sky
-darkened (burn) the clouds
-darkened (burn) the shadow side of the building
-darkened (brun) the shadow on the FG grass from the building
-lightened (dodge) the reflection in the window
-lightened (dodge) the dog
-added a tad of selective contrast to just the window reflection
-added a tad of global contrast
-added a tad of global USM (sharpening) to get over the AA filter
-healed out the white specs in the grass
Note: Dodge and burn is not that hard to learn the trick is to let
nature do most of the work and just lighten or darken what is already
there. Try to avoid creating new light.
Hope this helps and thanks for posting.
Take care,
Dwayne Oakes