Apparently it has almost turned into a sport to make fun of Rockwell.
But personally I dont have much to complain about him. He offered a nice intro into photography. Because of him I became interested in DSLRs, and prime lenses, and photographic technique. His site isnt so bad if you want to learn photography.
Because of him, I got a D5100, 18-55mm, 55-200mm, and 35mm. A great starter kit to try out photography - cheap, lightweight, and able to deliver good results if used properly.
The only bad advice he ever gave me was the SB400 flash. A most useless thing. Whatever you do, you really should get a flash you can rotate around and put off the camera.
I guess I just dont have an issue reading someones opinion and forming my own, instead of following any advice to the letter, like some sort of slave ?
For example I didnt buy his advice to photograph only to JPEG because I figured he was just wired to "make it right in camera" from his film days. But a camera records 14 bits of data per pixel and a JPEG only stores 8, so thats obviously a huge loss.