Looking to the past

[Roger]

I processed this shot with a view to photos from the past....

 

[tranceplant]

I like it and the idea is good, but it looks a bit ''over done'' like too perfect.

 

[Roger]

I like it and the idea is good, but it looks a bit ''over done'' like too perfect.

glad you like it....but do you mean it looks fake?

 

[Antarctican]

I love the composition and subject matter of the shot, but the processing (noticeable vertical lines, especially in the water in the foreground) is a bit distracting to me

 

[Mohain]

I have to agree with everything Anti says. It's a great photo, great comp, a timeless shot. But the texture spoils it for me.

 

[platano]

yeah.. i would go a lil bit easy on the texture, I would of done it for you.. but "your photos are NOT ok to edit"

 

[Roger]

I love the composition and subject matter of the shot, but the processing (noticeable vertical lines, especially in the water in the foreground) is a bit distracting to me

thanks for the comment...I did debate with myself whether the texture was a bit too much.

I have to agree with everything Anti says. It's a great photo, great comp, a timeless shot. But the texture spoils it for me.

thanks Mohain.

yeah.. i would go a lil bit easy on the texture, I would of done it for you.. but "your photos are NOT ok to edit"

thanks for commenting.

 

[Roger]

following the above comments I decided on a different edit.