What's new

Need advice on edited photo

Bolero

TPF Noob!
Joined
Nov 3, 2013
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Location
Ohio
Can others edit my Photos
Photos NOT OK to edit
Hi all...I just recently saw a photo of my son in a store used in advertisement. They actually edited his hair to look like he is a girl. I don't know where they got the photo but we never had any event or anything to give permission to anybody. What can I do?
thanks for any advice.
 
I want to but a little hesitant if I have valid legal issues. I'm sure it's my son with the hair photoshopped or something.
 
No, that's not what I meant. I want to know if I have copyright issue here. Can they alter a photo and use it without my permission? I'm searching on my files to see if I have that original photo.
 
No, that's not what I meant. I want to know if I have copyright issue here. Can they alter a photo and use it without my permission? I'm searching on my files to see if I have that original photo.

If it's a photo you took, having the original photo will do you no good. What you need, in order to pursue it in the legal arena, is a registration for that image with the US Copyright Office. If you didn't do that, you're basically SOL.

Copyright infringment is strictly a federal matter (in the US), and must be pursued in federal courts. And without a registration, you won't find a lawyer that will take the case as you cannot file without the registration.
 
No, that's not what I meant. I want to know if I have copyright issue here. Can they alter a photo and use it without my permission? I'm searching on my files to see if I have that original photo.

If it's a photo you took, having the original photo will do you no good. What you need, in order to pursue it in the legal arena, is a registration for that image with the US Copyright Office. If you didn't do that, you're basically SOL.

Copyright infringment is strictly a federal matter (in the US), and must be pursued in federal courts. And without a registration, you won't find a lawyer that will take the case as you cannot file without the registration.

Perhaps, the issue is one of using a recognizable reproduction of someone (the son) in a commercial without a valid model release?
 
How do I pursue that?
 
How do I pursue that?

Not being a lawyer, and not living in the USA, don't really know. I think Keith's suggestion needs to be a starting point, probably a lawyer with intellectual property, or commercial media experience. I'd also think that you need to put together a file documenting the use and include an affidavit that no authorization to use the image was ever given.
 
A qualified attorney will help you determine if you have a valid legal issue. One a state law issue, and another that is covered by federal law.

I am not an attorney, but I am familiar with the legal environment that applies to photography and the uses of photography.

In general, an advertiser needs permission (a valid, signed, model release) to use someone's likeness in an advertisement.
If the person's likeness that is used is a minor, the advertiser needs the written permission (a valid, signed, model release) of the minors parents.
Model release law is state law and varies by state, which is why you need an Ohio attorney.
An issue over the release of someones likeness for a commercial use would be heard in state court.

The theft of images off the Internet is rampant.
If you have posted images of your son on the Internet that you have taken, it may be that someone copied the one you have seen as an advertisement.

If you took the original photo, you also own the copyright to the photo, and again an advertiser needs copyright owner permission to use the photo in an advertisement.
That separate issue is called copyright infringement.

Copyright law is federal law. Copyright infringement cases are heard in federal court.
However. For the copyright issue to have legal weight the copyright needs to be registered with the US Copyright Office. Help! I?ve Been Infringed! | Photo Attorney
Copyright registration timing is critical to protecting all your legal rights to an image, and determine if statutory or actual damages can be sought.
Actual damages are just what they say, have to be proven, and often the actual damages are substantially less than the cost of hiring an attorney and going to court. But, there is no upper limit to actual damages, and whatever profits the infringer made from the infringement can be included as part of the actual damages awarded by the court.

Statutory damages are set by copyright law, so no $$$ amount has to be proven. If an infringer can prove they were unaware they were infringing, the court has discretion to lower the statutory award from the minimum of $750, to $200.
If the plaintiff's (your) attorney can prove an infringement was willful, the maximum award the court can give is $150,000 (per infringed image) plus all attorney and court costs.

See - § 504 · Remedies for infringement: Damages and profits b and c - http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap5.pdf

U.S. Copyright Office - Copyright Law of the United States
U.S. Copyright Office
 
First off, you need to make sure it's your image that's been used.

But before you trot off to the lawyer's office, contact the infringer and state that your image was used without permission. Instead of threatening legal action, merely make an offer that they agree to use the image as they have, and sign a contract to that affect. Return the signed contract back to you with a check for $X and all will be well.
 
I'm wondering on what site the photo was posted where someone was able to obtain it. The reason is that many websites have Terms & Conditions that allow third parties to use photos from the site - people using a website may not realize what they agreed to. You might want to look at the Terms on the site where the photo was posted to help you figure out where you stand. I would expect a reputable business to hire photographers or pay for photos for their ads but you most likely aren't exactly dealing with a reputable business.

You could look on American Society of Media Photographers 's site, go to Business Resources then go to Tutorials and Guides and scroll down thru options, or Business & Legal FAQ's.
 
Editing your son to look like a girl constitutes an infringement of his rights. Contact a lawyer. If you own the image you can pursue copyright infringement as well but even if you don't, that is your son and he is being made to look female. A good lawyer will win a cease and desist and a great lawyer will win you damages.
 

Most reactions

New Topics

Back
Top Bottom