over-edited or not?

[scrutiny1]

This picture was taken while I was on a sailing trip in Washington.

I was wondering if it is too yellow or if there is something I could do to make it better.

Here is an unedited picture of similar composition.

Thanks!

 

[Michaelaw]

I prefer the unedited version, what is it you're trying to achieve in post?

 

[immski]

I like the PS one better

 

[scrutiny1]

I'm sorry, what does PS mean?

 

[Michaelaw]

Photoshop

 

[scrutiny1]

hehe thx..
me= noob

 

[ksmattfish]

I prefer the composition and color in the edited version (1st post). The color doesn't look natural, but I'm okay with that.

 

[Mr Avid]

I cropped this a little to make the horizon more of a focal point....added a little blue.... it makes the light on the water seem a little more directional.

 

[Alex_B]

i think the first edit pushed the colour of the water a bit in the wrong direction.

apart from that it is fine I think.

 

[Flash Harry]

my go, could be a bit dark: