I've got the 1450 Orange with foam. I only use it kayaking so to the person saying why get bright Orange? It can be seen much easier floating down the river. (Not that this is likely to happen as I have it strapped to the kayak). As far as foam/padding, the padding would be much easier to reconfigure as needs change, but I find the foam to be much better at holding the gear firm in place. Given the choice I'd probably opt for padding, but since I got mine for $50 or so off of someone who won it and never used it (Foam still intact), I didn't have the option. These are great either inside you get. You can always buy the other insert if you really want to switch the one you have.