I like the first one a lot. The textures of the treads and the lighting are interesting, and the composition is good - you could try cropping a little on the left and top to make the edge of the tires a little closer to a corner-to-corner diagonal - might not work as well, but take a look - this would also remove some spots on the top tire that are right on the edge of the frame and maybe a little distracting. You could darken the lighter tires a little bit and gradually as you go towards the right edge - this would make the OOF parts less obvious. I'd also try to recover some detail in that bright spot in the middle. I hope this was shot in raw.