Could the second and third photo be the same?
If so, I sort of like that "one" (?) better than the first, though focus is better in 1 (if I remember right - if the photos were directly showing in the thread, it would be easier to tell), but I miss part of that duck's body there, so compositionally I feel Photo 1 is lacking a bit. The head seems --- to be alone... if you see what I mean?