#1 probably looks pretty good seen BIG on a decent monitor. Reduced to 800x pixel width, it looks less-impressive. I looked at it carefully...the water droplets, and the subtle lighting on the head and bill versus the brighter lighting on the body plumage is, well, very subtle and delicate. The crop is a bit awkward, I think, maybe a bit too much water top, and too muchy on the right hand side, yet still, it does have an offbeat allure. The second shot, while full-body, seems coarser to me, rather more mundane, more point at a swan and click, but the lighting is nice, and the reflection is nice.