adamwilliamking
TPF Noob!
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2009
- Messages
- 481
- Reaction score
- 0
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos NOT OK to edit
I was just thinking about the broad critique we get around here.
I mean broad as in, one person will nail every technical aspect of photography and give you whats wrong with yours, well others will just kind of praise photos they think look "cool". Not that one persons is better than the others, because art cannot be good or bad, you can only like it or not like it. Anyways..
I was thinking it would be nice if newer posters (and old) had a way of telling how effective ones suggestions might be.
Than I thought of a way that we could get that across and the only thing I could come up with is a thank you system that I have seen and used on other forums.
Anyone think this might be a good idea?
That way if someone helps you out you can hit their thank you buttom, they are usually displayed in the quick user panel that shows up when you post, so the poster could use that information to kind of take the comment lighter than they might if it was an experienced poster who has already received many thanks.
yay, nah?
I mean broad as in, one person will nail every technical aspect of photography and give you whats wrong with yours, well others will just kind of praise photos they think look "cool". Not that one persons is better than the others, because art cannot be good or bad, you can only like it or not like it. Anyways..
I was thinking it would be nice if newer posters (and old) had a way of telling how effective ones suggestions might be.
Than I thought of a way that we could get that across and the only thing I could come up with is a thank you system that I have seen and used on other forums.
Anyone think this might be a good idea?
That way if someone helps you out you can hit their thank you buttom, they are usually displayed in the quick user panel that shows up when you post, so the poster could use that information to kind of take the comment lighter than they might if it was an experienced poster who has already received many thanks.
yay, nah?