Tokyo Density

[dancer]

I have been going through my old Tokyo shots and retouching them. This was a fun one that I wanted to try in B&W. What do you think?


DSC_4310 by Nadia & Casey Photography, on Flickr

 

[KenC]

This is a good image, but I think it suffers from being so small on the screen. Something this detailed needs to be really large - projected or printed at least 11x14 inches or so.

Obviously I haven't seen the color version to compare, but it works well in bw - there is a good tonal range and the image works being about shapes and tones rather than color. Nice touch that the buildings gradually get taller from bottom to top.

 

[aadhils]

This is a good image, but I think it suffers from being so small on the screen. Something this detailed needs to be really large - projected or printed at least 11x14 inches or so.

Obviously I haven't seen the color version to compare, but it works well in bw - there is a good tonal range and the image works being about shapes and tones rather than color. Nice touch that the buildings gradually get taller from bottom to top.

I don't think it would be wise to post the picture too large on a forum hence the link below:

All sizes | DSC_4310 | Flickr - Photo Sharing!

I personally think that the image could do with being a bit brighter like so:

 

[KenC]

This is a good image, but I think it suffers from being so small on the screen. Something this detailed needs to be really large - projected or printed at least 11x14 inches or so.

Obviously I haven't seen the color version to compare, but it works well in bw - there is a good tonal range and the image works being about shapes and tones rather than color. Nice touch that the buildings gradually get taller from bottom to top.

I don't think it would be wise to post the picture too large on a forum hence the link below:

All sizes | DSC_4310 | Flickr - Photo Sharing!

Yes, I saw that and you can see it a little better there, but it still needs to be seen larger. I was just commenting on a possible reason for the lack of responses, and not advocating posting a larger image.

 

[Derrel]

The image is nice, but at small sizes, it lacks much impact. Yes...it is the city...but without a tangible, sufficient reward, why would people bother commenting?

 

[pbelarge]

The edited version looks overexposed.