Tried my first B&W HDR. C&C please

[OregonT3i]

I originally did this image in color, with mixed results. I am brand new to HDR right now. I shoot lots of B&W, so I decided to see how this scene would look as a B&W HDR. I like the way it came out personally, but I would like some C&C, as I'm always looking to improve my work. Thanks for looking.

 

[Bynx]

HDR with its tonal range looks really nice as greyscale. In addition, greyscale can also cover a multitude of sins done to the color version. I cant seem to remember seeing a B&W of an HDR image that I thought looked bad.

 

[o hey tyler]

It looks good as far as the HDR is concerned... But unless the lightening is going to reflect in the water as well, I'd remove it. Just looks too fake.