Thoughts? Is it an improvement?
It could be called an improvement, at least for the position of the prop.
Please take these comments to heart, and in the spirit in which they are offered, namely; helpful criticism.
Use vertical (portrait) orientation.
Modify your flash to be less harsh.
Ask your model to look at the lens and attempt a smile.
Move your light a bit to the front.
Move your model away from the backdrop.
Focus on her eye.
When you post a shot, click on "full size". (The preferred size is about 1,000 pixels on the longest side.)
Oh, I see you were reposting it larger when I was typing, so never mind that part.