FOTO-GRAFFIC
TPF Noob!
danalec99 said:I see where you are coming from, but allow me to be Devil's Advocate's Devil's Advocate.
What if the creator is content with the 'filtered' and/or the 'lensbabied' version?
What if one does not want to? What if the creator made all the creative decisions while he/she was looking through the viewfinder?
You are of course correct in making that assumption as the creator/author of the image used the device knowing what it would do. My worry/concern is that this takes something away from the creator being able to change the effect at a later time. I have gone back to images that I took 10 & 15 years ago and re-worked them in a different style to bring out a different aspect of what I was trying to achieve in the first instance. That siad I defend the right of anyone to use what devices they like to achieve the effects they want to convey - but when the Lensbaby falls from grace - as it will just like some of the effects that we had in the days of wet hands and feeling around in the dark, then what of these images.
Some of the truely great photographs and photographers have used an image several times and bought out different characteristics which appeal to a different audience. I cannot argue (nor will I) against your premise here but only wish to point out that it restricts the creator and in doing so reduces the use of such an image.