With the exception of "C&C Please" threads, one could do an exhaustive search on any topic presented and, in 90% of cases, find another thread with a similar subject.
- I sometimes have trouble finding my own posts with the TPF search engine.
Really? This is a piece-of-cake:
- Click on "Search"
Etc., etc., etc.
Beside the point. If I may be allowed a metaphor, I'm telling you the car does not run very fast and your response is to point out where the accelerator pedal is. I say the car does not perform and you assume I need driving lessons. Well I know where the accelerator is and I do not need driving lessons. I'm saying the car will not win the Indy 500.
You're also misunderstanding what I meant by "finding my own posts." I'm saying that I know for a fact I posted a comment with the word "discombobulated" in it but I can't find it. The SE returns no hits.
Also, the fact that it's a "piece-of-cake" only reinforces what I'm saying. For all its "advanced" features the search engine is not very sophisticated. It's a simple word finder with no capability for logical searches, regular expressions or AI searches. Probably took some programmer less than a day to write and debug it, assuming he did not simply copy it out of a textbook.
I submit that the primary purpose of this or any other forum is to foster a sense of camaraderie, rather than to slowly compile an exhaustive and non-redundant encyclopedia (that's the Wiki's job).
I submit that the primary purpose of this or any other forum that has advertising is to make money for the forum owners.
Right. And the primary purpose of a TV station or cable network is also to make money for their owners. But the TV station's customers are the advertisers, not the viewers. I don't watch TV for the commercials any more than I drive down the highway to read the billboards. I watch TV to be entertained and to get me to watch their shows (and maybe their commercials) the TV station/network has to offer me the service for free or at a nominal price. In the same vein I don't come here to read the ads; I come for the forum.
Visitors see all the advertisements and out number members about 5 to 1 so the Forum owners actually make money off those of us that generate their main content.
And I say we should be paid for that content. :lmao:
The only reason I mentioned it though was because this sort of thread tends to get heavily debated and there is no reason for it to get started again.
By that logic there's no need for Hollywood to make sequels, but they do. Why? To make money. But nobody forces you to go see
Godfather II or
Rambo IV.
If "this sort of thread tends to get heavily debated" it's because members are interested. If they are interested then they read, they post, maybe read the ads and the interests of the forum owners are served.
So let the individual forum member decide for himself whether he wants to read (and post) on a subject that's already been discussed. That's called
freedom of choice. A rule that says you can't start a new thread on a subject that's already been discussed is called censorship.