A Few Recent HDR's {C&C}

[robertandrewphoto]

1

2

3

Please give me your honest opinion on my shots, I understand it is all constructive criticism.

 

[Live_free]

All are extremely over-baked and you ruined the point of HDR. IMO

 

[robertandrewphoto]

k.

and btw, telling someone they ruined hdr is anything but constructive criticism

way to ruin the point of a forum meant to help photographers

 

[pbelarge]

"Please give me your honest opinion on my shots, I understand it is all constructive criticism"


From Websters 11th Edition:
a view, judgement, or appraisal formed in the mind about a particular matter


When you post on a public forum with individuals from varied backrounds, they are not necessarily going to have the same opinion as you. So, expect "opinions" that may not make you happy...but try to squeeze what you can out of the answer to help you...even if you do not like it. Also, just as the opinionated individuals may not suit you, take it with a grain of salt and move on.

If you complain about people's opinions, someone who may have an opinion that you like may not post.

 

[Live_free]

k.

and btw, telling someone they ruined hdr is anything but constructive criticism

way to ruin the point of a forum meant to help photographers

Also I would say it is, by me telling you that should infer to tone it down and not increase the bracketing stops so drastically.