I like the feel of #2.... Its a bit soft and my eyes are drawn to the in focus area just behind the woman.
#1 is has great texture and tone. The lighting is perfect... even a tiny bit of light caught in the man's eyes gives the photo some significant depth. I would have cropped out some of the space above the man's head. This would bring the eye level a little farther away from the center half.
I like #1 a lot. I've always said the best pictures are the ones that invoke an emotional response in the viewer and this one succeeds in doing exactly that. Plus, it's sharp and I like the depth of field. My only nitpick (and it's minor) is the chopped off half of his arm.
#2, I'll just say I'm not personally a fan of the whole tilted camera thing and leave it at that.
Nice work Number one have an excellent composition and Drama but I love the number 2 even with the soft look it add a little bit of romance to the photo