Graduated Neutral Density filter

mattvillano · Dec 15, 2004

Does anyone know anything about this filter and whether it is quality?
http://www.adorama.com/LEPND6G.html

I've been looking to buy a Grad ND filter and I don't want to spend a fortune but I don't want to get a cheap one like the Cokin's which alter colors. If not this one can anyone recommend good ones or places to find them. Thanks.

walter23 · Dec 16, 2004

Are cokins really considered cheap? I've only heard good things about them, but maybe that's only because of the convenience of using their drop-in system?

Hertz van Rental · Dec 16, 2004

They are fine for amateur use but never use a grad with a zoom. As you extend the focal length the grad line becomes quite a sharp edge and looks really false. Grads are all designed to work with a standard lens.

mattvillano · Dec 16, 2004

walter23 said:
Are cokins really considered cheap? I've only heard good things about them, but maybe that's only because of the convenience of using their drop-in system?

All the articles and tipes I've been reading have said to stay away from the Cokin grad ND filters because they aren't actually a neutral tone, just grey. So they tend to create unwanted color casts in color film.

Jamie R · Dec 16, 2004

Sad to hear Cokin's whole line of Z-Pro and X-Pro filters all get the same bashing that the A(mateur) and P systems deserve.

The A+ P systems use a cheap dye resin which is just awful; but it isn't a problem if you're shooting black and white photography on the cheap (wot' at $5 a piece or less?!).

The Z-Pro and X-Pro system use a higher grade of resin which is neutral density proper, instead of just grey-dyed. The prices reflect the higher grade, and these are still cheaper than Lee filters. They scratch badly and often though. The drop in system is useful - even for wide-angle lenses.