a reflection

[Mike Lamb]

I really like it all except for your reflection. Something interesting, emotional or provocative is needed to make this better than OK.

 

[mmaria]

I really like it all except for your reflection. Something interesting, emotional or provocative is needed to make this better than OK.

OK then, thanks for letting me know

 

[Mike Lamb]

I really like it all except for your reflection. Something interesting, emotional or provocative is needed to make this better than OK.

OK then, thanks for letting me know

I assume when you said, c c welcome, you meant it. I think everything is good about the image except your reflection.

 

[sleist]

I kind of agree with Mike here. The frame with the tree and the 2 people walking could be a nice image on it's own.
Expanding the frame to the reflection is interesting, but it doesn't really add anything.
Expanding further to the image as posted, I feel like there is nothing that adds to the composition in any positive way - rather, it goes downhill quickly.
This is one of those images that connects more with the photographer than the viewer.

My 2 cents.

 

[mmaria]

I really like it all except for your reflection. Something interesting, emotional or provocative is needed to make this better than OK.

OK then, thanks for letting me know

I assume when you said, c c welcome, you meant it. I think everything is good about the image except your reflection.

Of course I meant it. I know that everyone wont like everything, I don't expect that, at all. I just didn't understand that underlined text you wrote.

 

[mmaria]

I kind of agree with Mike here. The frame with the tree and the 2 people walking could be a nice image on it's own.
Expanding the frame to the reflection is interesting, but it doesn't really add anything.
Expanding further to the image as posted, I feel like there is nothing that adds to the composition in any positive way - rather, it goes downhill quickly.
This is one of those images that connects more with the photographer than the viewer.

My 2 cents.

Thanks for sharing your opinion. And please don't take it like I said that in a negative way.

My intent with this image was a selfportrait but also adding the story to it. It's ok if you don't find it ok.