Are the houses a distraction?

[MissMia]

I really like the fourth edit. The houses don't bother me in the image. Beautiful shot of Superstition too.

 

[jv17]

i dont see any houses here but that is a good picture

 

[teneighty23]

i like your original B+W best, and i like the idea of #1, just a little too much detail is lost. so i like #3

 

[Mohain]

Wow, great shot. I'd either go with 4 or 1. I think I'd prefer 1 but the middle right highlight is a bt much for me.

 

[Mohain]

i like your original B+W best, and i like the idea of #1, just a little too much detail is lost.

Agree with the above

 

[duncanp]

i like the first one the best and the houses in my opinion are a valuable addition as they provide a sense of scale.

 

[resevordg]

i like the first one the best and the houses in my opinion are a valuable addition as they provide a sense of scale.

Thats a really good point. I had not thought of that.

I think its so interesting to hear how different people like one edit of this photo over the other. All of you have really good reasons and they are all different.