1. I think the crop is too tight... it makes me feel claustrophobic and all crammed in
2. I like the shot but the vignetting is too extreme Ithink.
3. Another good picture, but the subject of the picture is the couple. I like the idea of highlighting his military status, but it's just distracting in this case, because it isn't the subject of the picture.
4. Not working for me from the standpoint that the guy's position is awkward and you really can't see the picture in the camera clearly
5. Best shot, love it! The vignette is just right, you captured her joy, and the ring takes a prominent position in the photo without being a distraction. Awesome
-tim