Feedback Needed :)

[JuliaM]

Hi there, just joined the forum and hoping to get some feedback on a few of my favorite pieces! : )

 

[timethief]

Welcome to the forum Julia.
The b/w rose looks the only good shoot among all. Actually it is more than good, very very good.
The other 3 have composition issues. I remember we had few very good photographers shooting flowers here on the forum. Look up their work.

 

[PapaMatt]

I like the B&W also, very very nice

 

[Big Mike]

Welcome aboard.

I agree with the previous comments, the B&W rose is a great photo. The others don't do much for me.

 

[Frequency]

Yes...B&W is the best,,,violet would have been lovely if the flowers were fully within the frame...the remaining two are compositional problems as already been pointed out'
O, forgot...Hearty Welcome