I have enjoyed reading this thread, and seeing where all of you are coming from.
I think it is still too early to tell about where I am at. I am an artist, therefore I want to be an artistic photographer. For now I will still try to shoot everything to find my strengths and weeknesses. I have noticed that I am most often not good capturing a large scene, and when I get home to go over what I have captured, I often find smaller things I find exciting or interesting in the bigger picture. I didn't catch on to this for a while either. But now I see it, and I am teaching myself that I can look for the smaller stuff, and I am finding my niche, or my love through this medium.
I also love post processing, and am training my self to see in the field what colors I can bring out later. I have learned that I love abstract photography, and that I need to really learn the language of composition. I know I will never be a wedding photographer. I don't know that I'll even be good at portraiture. What I see is, if I ever hope to earn a dime from this hobby, it will be from an artistic view of the world.
Time will tell. Right now I want to learn as much as I can, as fast as I can, and become adept at applying what I learn.