I need some feedback please

[vandecarr]

 

[cameramike]

strange i have a picture just like your first one. the last two i really like the contrast is good perhaps the last one in pure b\w would look better?

overall i like the last two, the first one is just to much sky with to little of a subject.

 

[LaFoto]

Oops, your second photo presented is going to leak soon! The water will run out of it on the left! Quick, straighten it to prevent this from happening!!! :shock:

I like the last very much. Simple scene, just the island with the copse, the windblown water and the clouds. But - like cameramike - also I feel a straight b&w might work even better.

Nice attempt with the bird, but it is really too small, I feel.

 

[vandecarr]

thanks for the input. I appreciate it.

 

[Darton]

HAHAHA I thought that the first two were one picture and I was trying to figure out why there was a gray band through the center of the shot. Now i realize that it's two pictures. Ohh i feel like such a ditz sometimes. I agree with total B&W on #3 and straighten #2

 

[spiffybeth]

i like the first, but i love the third!