I have friends in Chicago, apparently, you guys are getting pummled with snow a heck of a lot more than even we are in Montrreal. Our grass is still green here!
Catchlights are a part of portraiture and nothing wrong with them. My personal take is that I like the smaller round ones. There are people who use huge sofboxes and it clearly shows in the eyes, or 2-3 light setups and each light is clearly reflected in the eyes. I try to play with the lighting and poses in such a way that one is seen.
As long as the lights are off camera, and no red-eye is happening, it's all good.