Just a plane crop

[Tight Knot]

Hi all,

Looking for C&C on the crop of these 3 photos (other C&C is also welcome).

If you feel that none of these crops works, I would love to see your crops.

(Truth is, I really don't like the first one, even though it gives me the plane, and the space on the left of the frame to follow the gaze of the "ramper" (or ramp service agent), and I personally like the last the best)

EDIT - (funny, but the order I put them in, is not the order I've mentioned above. In the order that they are in here, I dislike the last, but like the 3rd the most, followed by the first, then the 2nd)

Thanks,

Bruce

 

[The_Traveler]

For me, the second or third work equally well..

 

[Tight Knot]

For me, the second or third work equally well..

Thanks Lew, please see my edit above.

 

[The_Traveler]

Sorry, I'm lost.
Which is the edit you referred to?

 

[Tight Knot]

Sorry, I'm lost.
Which is the edit you referred to?

LOL, the edit in red writing in my original post showing which one I really like, and which one I really don't.

 

[snowbear120 51]

For me, one (top left) or either on the bottom (three and four). I prefer the closer crops of the ramper.

 

[The_Traveler]

Sorry, a bit dull today.
I think the composition is very good but the shadow is so deep and dull and blue that it needs someone better than me to make it really good.
Tough exposure, huge dynamic range and through a window (?)

 

[Tight Knot]

For me, one (top left) or either on the bottom (three and four). I prefer the closer crops of the ramper.

Thanks Snowbear.

 

[mmaria]

top right for me

 

[Tight Knot]

Sorry, a bit dull today.
I think the composition is very good but the shadow is so deep and dull and blue that it needs someone better than me to make it really good.
Tough exposure, huge dynamic range and through a window (?)View attachment 87217

Thanks Lew.
The plane was still moving at that stage, and I had but one chance to get the shot. No question that the shadows are too deep and blue, but no matter how much I played with it, I couldn't get anything that looked realistic.
If we weren't moving, I would have bracketed the shot.
And yes, it was through a window. My days of riding on the wing, on the top of the plane or dangling under a perfectly good plane with nothing but a piece of cloth and some string between me and the sky, and me between the above mentioned and the earth, are loooong gone (although I do sometimes miss the freedom).

 

[Tight Knot]

top right for me

Thanks mmaria

 

[KenC]

What, no poll?

Third (bottom left, just to be certain) - the most balanced. I think it looks fine as is. Making the sun-lit part of the runway a little lighter might be good.

 

[waday]

Third and fourth for me.

 

[Tight Knot]

What, no poll?

Third (bottom left, just to be certain) - the most balanced. I think it looks fine as is. Making the sun-lit part of the runway a little lighter might be good.

Thanks KenC, maybe I should make a poll to see if people want me to make a poll

Third is my favourite also, I'll try to lighten up the lit part of the runway to see how it looks.

 

[Tight Knot]

Third and fourth for me.

Thanks waday