You crack me up I am starting to believe if their will ever be an image that you just simply like. No photo is going to be picture perfect in your book hehe. Anyway im joking with you I can see your point about the water but what else can I do ask the sky to move for me because it's in the shot LOL.
Well Provo Im sure in every shot there is something wrong. Perhaps the OP doesnt notice or hopes others wont. Im just pointing out what I see is odd. Personally Id prefer to get some kind of comment than nothing at all. And I never blow smoke. Looking again Im wondering how much HDR affected the very sharp edges of the reflections.
@Bynx: I think Provo did some EDITING for the light and reflections which you are talking.. the original image will be much different than which I see here.
I would say that the water was a little to far on the murkey side, you might have gotten away with useing a softening filter to hide some of the blemished
I think it's an excellent shot. The water looked something in the lands of fantasy, with its shiny twinkling effect. The koifish looked like fish fairies, lol..I like the shot of it. It has a mysterious-fantasy effect.