My Uncle's Yard

[pm63]

Click for larger:



I'm not sure about this one. Any comments would be appreciated.

 

[pm63]

Any feedback at all?

 

[LaFoto]

Even the larger version on Flickr looks sharp to the point of "oversharpened", and all in all I can only think "My God, when is ever anyone going to tidy this place up???" It looks cluttered ... because the place IS cluttered. Not sure if photographing this is art? The tones seem ok enough. But is it really THAT interesting for a viewer to look at? Not to me, I'm afraid.

 

[pm63]

Even the larger version on Flickr looks sharp to the point of "oversharpened", and all in all I can only think "My God, when is ever anyone going to tidy this place up???" It looks cluttered ... because the place IS cluttered. Not sure if photographing this is art? The tones seem ok enough. But is it really THAT interesting for a viewer to look at? Not to me, I'm afraid.

Thanks for the feedback. Keep in mind that flickr adds sharpening to images, and this isn't the first time one of my shots has come out oversharpened when viewed large on flickr. I thought the clutter was quite interesting personally (btw, this is just his 'work' corner, he isn't a messy person, honest!).

Judging by the overall lack of response, I think this is one of those shots which the photographer likes due to personal involvement, but this isn't apparent to other viewers of the image.