need feedback on photos

[jazzphoto]

Looking for some feedback..

http://

 

[bobnr32]

A pleasant shot with nice tonal range. I would have cropped the top a bit. It also would be better if there were a figure or dog maybe somewhere in the pic. Only my opinion.

 

[bazooka]

It feels incomplete to me. I agree that something in the bottom right corner would help to balance the image. Otherwise I feel like I really need to see the rest of the barn.

 

[sparks017]

Like everyone else has said so far, I agree that something is missing in the photo, and the top of the photo should be cropped just a little. In my opinion I would said that the contrast on the black and white should be a little more. Other than that great concept.

 

[Frequency]

Since the main object of this shot is very heavy, it is always better to leave some breathing space; of course i found it good

 

[KenC]

There is much more detail and contrast in the barn than anywhere else, so I find the sky, trees and ground to be just distractions from the real image. Of course you have to include little of these, but I would crop tighter. This is a subject that demands closer shots of its parts. If you can go back, get closer and get more detail.