Old Wrecks

BananaRepublic · Sep 4, 2014

I'd to like to get some feedback on these just as a gauge really.

The two of the blue tractor are tight but it was all I could do at the time.

I know about the thing on the top left of the first image and I think the sky in the second isn't correct.

Thanks

Tinderbox (UK) · Sep 4, 2014

Looks better in B/W

John

Warhorse · Sep 4, 2014

Color looks better to me.

pthrift · Sep 4, 2014

I really like the close crop on the middle picture

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S4; probably while slacking off at work

Designer · Sep 4, 2014

BananaRepublic said:
.. just as a gauge really.

In the color shots the color seems off.

AlanKlein · Sep 4, 2014

The BW is tight too especially on the bottom. But I like it better than the colors. The color one's lighting and colors looks like they were HDR'ed? Don't look natural. What are you doing in processing to cause this?

BananaRepublic · Sep 4, 2014

I don't think I have much leeway on the bottom of the B&W but I have on the sides. The clarity on the two colours has been pushed up and highlights, I just wanted to see what people thought, there kind of ordinary as is so I just went in with a lead foot.