What's new

On the Edge

JTPhotography

No longer a newbie, moving up!
Joined
Dec 8, 2012
Messages
902
Reaction score
428
Location
South Mississippi
Can others edit my Photos
Photos NOT OK to edit
Shot this yesterday morning. I live for these types of photo ops.

$edge of heaven.webp
 
Extremely well-executed. Nice shot! Love how the reflection looks so surreal. Super well-done!
 
Yeah, great shot.
 
Thanks folks! :)

Its funny, I posted this on 500px and a few other sites and got several comments about it being photoshopped or a "manipulation". Now I admit that there was a bit of luck here in that I got the composition right and didn't even have to crop it. A very minor contrast bump and unsharp mask and that's it. I wouldn't even know where to begin in faking something like this. If I did, I am too damn lazy for that. LOL I don't get it. Maybe it makes people feel better to think that it is not possible to get something like this straight out of the camera, or damn close to it. Ok, I am done venting. :)
 
Well if your going to be an evil manipulator you've got a lot of work to do - trust me, I've already survived 2 daughters going through their teenage years and I'm working on surviving the third - lol. Great shot, absolutely love it, wouldn't change a thing.
 
Thanks folks! :)

Its funny, I posted this on 500px and a few other sites and got several comments about it being photoshopped or a "manipulation". Now I admit that there was a bit of luck here in that I got the composition right and didn't even have to crop it. A very minor contrast bump and unsharp mask and that's it. I wouldn't even know where to begin in faking something like this. If I did, I am too damn lazy for that. LOL I don't get it. Maybe it makes people feel better to think that it is not possible to get something like this straight out of the camera, or damn close to it. Ok, I am done venting. :)

The reaction your photo garnered is largely a reflection of the crowd that hangs out at those type of aggregator sites; every day they see loads of images made at the software stage of the game, with the normal intent being, "Saturation Slider at Max!" and, "Vibrance + 50",and "Clarity +25". The majority of images seen there are heavily dependent upon a lot of processing effort being applied to, often, only mediocre scenes. Your photo on the other hand, doesn't show much in the way of excessive saturation or excessive clarity boost, or any of a host of other processing tricks. It's just a nice scene, with great clouds, and a good water surface for a clean reflection. But, at the popular aggregator sites, that's not the normal kind of image. Call what happened to your image "guilt by association".
 
Great shot, love the sky and reflections.
 
Very nice. Awesome sky. Probably even better if you were there 30 mins or so earlier...
 
Very nice. Awesome sky. Probably even better if you were there 30 mins or so earlier...

I was there about an hour before this. I was driving away when all of a sudden the angle of the sun hit just right to bring out the texture, it only lasted a few minutes. What you say makes perfect sense but I think what happened there were some very low clouds blocking the sun just at sunrise, when those moved away, this is what it revealed. Observing those subtle changes are something I have come to enjoy more and more.
 
Thanks folks! :)

Its funny, I posted this on 500px and a few other sites and got several comments about it being photoshopped or a "manipulation". Now I admit that there was a bit of luck here in that I got the composition right and didn't even have to crop it. A very minor contrast bump and unsharp mask and that's it. I wouldn't even know where to begin in faking something like this. If I did, I am too damn lazy for that. LOL I don't get it. Maybe it makes people feel better to think that it is not possible to get something like this straight out of the camera, or damn close to it. Ok, I am done venting. :)

The reaction your photo garnered is largely a reflection of the crowd that hangs out at those type of aggregator sites; every day they see loads of images made at the software stage of the game, with the normal intent being, "Saturation Slider at Max!" and, "Vibrance + 50",and "Clarity +25". The majority of images seen there are heavily dependent upon a lot of processing effort being applied to, often, only mediocre scenes. Your photo on the other hand, doesn't show much in the way of excessive saturation or excessive clarity boost, or any of a host of other processing tricks. It's just a nice scene, with great clouds, and a good water surface for a clean reflection. But, at the popular aggregator sites, that's not the normal kind of image. Call what happened to your image "guilt by association".

Well said, didn't think of it that way. Sometimes I think we need to invent a new word to define heavily post processed photography. Not knocking it if that is what a person does, particularly if they do it well, but it really is two different things.
 
Great shot.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
 
Holy crap that's good.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

New Topics

Back
Top Bottom