Please give me some feedback

[kunalb2301]

Hi All,

I am very new to photography and I request all you experts to give me some feedback so that I can imporve.

 

[lyonsroar]

I really like the first one!

 

[Marc-Etienne]

#1 is definitively your best one. Its warm and the silhouette is well composed:thumbup:
#2 is a classic, but always a winner and you did good with it
#3 is nice, but there is some noise around the bird's silhouette
#4 is not really interesting, no real subject and the colors are sad. Also there is a weird halo in the top left corner that looks like you pushed the PP too far
#5 is not really spectacular and once again, looks like the PP was pushed too far in for the sky

Overall, if that is where you start, that is really good in my humble opinion. I'm far from being a pro, I'm more like an "advanced noob" and I can tell you my beginning was worse than that for sure!!! Good job

 

[Randyh]

I like 2 and 5 the best.

 

[kunalb2301]

I really like the first one!

Thank you so much...

 

[kunalb2301]

#1 is definitively your best one. Its warm and the silhouette is well composed:thumbup:
#2 is a classic, but always a winner and you did good with it
#3 is nice, but there is some noise around the bird's silhouette
#4 is not really interesting, no real subject and the colors are sad. Also there is a weird halo in the top left corner that looks like you pushed the PP too far
#5 is not really spectacular and once again, looks like the PP was pushed too far in for the sky

Overall, if that is where you start, that is really good in my humble opinion. I'm far from being a pro, I'm more like an "advanced noob" and I can tell you my beginning was worse than that for sure!!! Good job

Thank you so much giving time to me and giving such a good feedback. I like your comment regarding 4th and 5th and now when you have said it I see these problem in these 2 picture.

 

[Marc-Etienne]

#1 is definitively your best one. Its warm and the silhouette is well composed:thumbup:
#2 is a classic, but always a winner and you did good with it
#3 is nice, but there is some noise around the bird's silhouette
#4 is not really interesting, no real subject and the colors are sad. Also there is a weird halo in the top left corner that looks like you pushed the PP too far
#5 is not really spectacular and once again, looks like the PP was pushed too far in for the sky

Overall, if that is where you start, that is really good in my humble opinion. I'm far from being a pro, I'm more like an "advanced noob" and I can tell you my beginning was worse than that for sure!!! Good job

Thank you so much giving time to me and giving such a good feedback. I like your comment regarding 4th and 5th and now when you have said it I see these problem in these 2 picture.

This is why I love constructive comments! Glad that you see it and can improve from there.
I'm happy to help out, keep them coming!

 

[Fujito]

I like 1.
2 & 3 are good for a beginner

It's a very natural thing for beginners to automatically center the horizon in landscape pictures. Try offsetting the horizon.

 

[mike3767]

2 & 3 are really good. Love the water drops on the flower. As for the last one, looks kinda "grainy"