I like 1 and 2, though 1 could do with a slight straightening out, unless my eyes are tricking me! It's quite interesting how you've broken the convergence with the girl climbing.
I like the light and silhouette in no. 2 and it does seem to tell a bit more of a story than the others. The star-shaped burst of light is very nice.
No. 3 looks like a model to me. The scale just seems a bit off; it makes the girl look tiny. It's quite strange, and I can't quite put my finger on it, but it's quite off-putting for me.