Rate the photo above you

[Destin]

I like the whole angels and ray of sunlight thing but the image looks a bit noisy. ISO 800 is a bit high, a wider aperture or longer exposure may have worked better.
7/10

Shot at f2.8, and around 1/60th of a second, at 200mm on my 70-200. Iso 800 was neccesary, and unfortunately my d80 doesn't handle it well. But I honestly don't mind the noise in this instance. It doesn't detract from the image like it normally would.

 

[Cfitz]

I like the panning done here and the focus is spot on. The colours are also nice, although I feel the car is too small in the frame. There's too much space above and below it. I'll give it a 7.5/10

 

[Sammie_Lou]

I give it an 8 out of 10. The only thing I'm not really crazy about is the amount of empty water below the sunset. I feel like maybe this would look better in landscape orientation.


170006_1779228761166_1252800005_2285459_6194146_o by SHerren88, on Flickr

 

[westerngirl14]

It's a nice photo. But I'm only going to give it a 6/10 because nothing truly stands out about it to me. Just another close up flower shot, and it looks over saturated. But the composition is nice.

[/IMG]

 

[Bitter Jeweler]

But it's red!

 

[Sammie_Lou]

It's a nice photo. But I'm only going to give it a 6/10 because nothing truly stands out about it to me. Just another close up flower shot, and it looks over saturated. But the composition is nice.

Thanks for the constructive feedback!

But it's red!

Actually, if you're talking about my flower, it was more of a magenta color. lol That one was taken with my P&S last summer.

 

[Sammie_Lou]

Since no one else is jumping in, I guess I'll keep playing...(keeping in mind here that I'm a total noob who has been at this for less than a month...) I like the image and the warm colors, but I wish I could see some more detail in the foreground. I give it a 7/10.


133490_1782549564184_1252800005_2293208_1034410_o by SHerren88, on Flickr

 

[Robin Usagani]

I give it a 5. Not enough action. The person needs to get shot or shooting.

 

[Sammie_Lou]

I give it a 5. Not enough action. The person needs to get shot or shooting.

Haha trust me! She got shot! And so did I, multiple times, in the process of taking those pics. In woodsball, the action is hard to get, though...most of the time, you don't see the players as they're shooting. They're hiding behinds all sorts of barriers. It's definitely a different kind of game to photograph. Can I ask for your critique on the photo, minus the "not enough action" thing?? I mean, the composition and all that jazz??

 

[westerngirl14]

I give it a 5. Not enough action. The person needs to get shot or shooting.

First of all, I really like this photo (Guess I can truly appreciate it, being a farm kid myself!) The subject is adorable, and so clearly in focus. The barn adds a nice background touch, too. Not in focus enough to be the subject, but hinting at the setting of this picture, and adding depth.
What I don't like is the large orange/yellow object the child appears to be sitting (standing?) in. What is it? It's distracting. I rate this 7.5/10

and my photo. Not usually a fan of reducing color saturation, but for this one I did...

[/IMG]

 

[Robin Usagani]

over exposed skin, blown background. You needed a flash. I have to give you really low pt.. a 3.5.

To explain the orange thingy.

 

[kundalini]

4/10. Messed up an opportunity to have the red, white & blue theme carry through with the carts.

 

[Robin Usagani]

I give it 9/10. To make it 10/10 I think you need to change the hue of the green grass to make it look like the other side. I think the green hurts your image. Nice image, looks like something i see on calendars. To keep old house look theme here it is. White border doesnt show very well on this website.

 

[kundalini]

Just to clarify... the other side is heavily ladened with fallen autumn leaves. My position was on the grassy knoll. And no, I'm not in Dallas.

 

[Sammie_Lou]

I give it 9/10. To make it 10/10 I think you need to change the hue of the green grass to make it look like the other side. I think the green hurts your image. Nice image, looks like something i see on calendars. To keep old house look theme here it is. White border doesnt show very well on this website.

The grass is always greener on the other side...