Rate the photo above you

[TCD photography]

5.5/10 I really like colors and everything about the photo, despite the AF's slipup.

 

[oldmacman]

Awesome colours. I love that blue set against the greens. Nice, sharp image... the focus looks spot on. 9/10

I saw this at the end of my driveway when I got home this evening. They're weeds, but I like the way the filaments are catching the setting sun.

 

[TCD photography]

7.5/10. I like that you chose the plant in the background. I would have shot more from the left, so that there was less space between the two stems, but that's just me.

 

[scottfishel]

Very nice scene, although i wish a little more of the cannon was in focus. 8/10.

 

[The_Traveler]

Nice scene but suffers a bit from the mostly hidden faces. The bright red colors and the badge on the boy's shoulder all pull the eye away from the points of interest. 6/10

I know this is just a family shot but I like it.

 

[SunnyHours]

It's an alright Snapshot...fill flash maybe...6/10

 

[Liamsford]

Nice shot, I would of raised the f stop which would of brought the sun out a bit more and have everything in focus... 7/10

 

[marmots]

5/10
its underexposed, there's too much negative space, and its just not a very interesting composition

 

[Sw1tchFX]

Marmots, I disagree. I think it's a beautiful image descriptive of more contemporary rural americana with a perfect exposure to capture that late evening sunset in the summer. Tells a story, brings back fond memories from my adolescence. 9/10

Now yours is HDR for the sake of HDR with a very tight composition and a subject which is in front of a background that doesn't add much context. Basically your picture says "this is my car in the driveway, i'm experimenting with HDR." 5/10


Guess I have to put one up now..

 

[marmots]

it wasnt even an hdr

 

[westerngirl14]

Marmots, I disagree. I think it's a beautiful image descriptive of more contemporary rural americana with a perfect exposure to capture that late evening sunset in the summer. Tells a story, brings back fond memories from my adolescence. 9/10

Now yours is HDR for the sake of HDR with a very tight composition and a subject which is in front of a background that doesn't add much context. Basically your picture says "this is my car in the driveway, i'm experimenting with HDR." 5/10


Guess I have to put one up now..

I'm sorry I can't see your picture... Can anyone else, or is it just me? aLL I see is a blue box with a ? mark in it. If others can see it, go ahead, I'll wait till a picture comes up my computer can read.

 

[kundalini]

I'm usually a big fan of your images Sw1tch, but these aren't saying much to me. Each are super sharp on your focal point, as expected. I much prefer the image on the right. I like the way you walk through the image, but I wish that hoop (for lack of a better term) was completely in frame. 7/10



(early days on a late evening)

 

[Dao]

7/10 Like the beautiful color and the peaceful feeling. If the bird on the right face the other direction will be perfect.
Question: How many birds are there in the photo?

 

[marmots]

Marmots, I disagree. I think it's a beautiful image descriptive of more contemporary rural americana with a perfect exposure to capture that late evening sunset in the summer. Tells a story, brings back fond memories from my adolescence. 9/10

Now yours is HDR for the sake of HDR with a very tight composition and a subject which is in front of a background that doesn't add much context. Basically your picture says "this is my car in the driveway, i'm experimenting with HDR." 5/10

i have to disagree
aside from the distracting background, and sure its a little tight, it was not a poorly composed image
i am not just learning hdr
it is not an hdr
the effect adds a lot to the original image, it actually tends to work well with cars
and your original hdr post was exactly what you just described of mine

as for the liamsford's image
it looks like someone pulled over and took a snapshot with their point and shoot

 

[TwoTwoLeft]

Funny, I thought this thread was titled "Rate the photo above you"....

Not "Rate the photo above you and debunk the last persons critique and give a new score for personal reasons."