It depends on what you are wanting to do with this photo. If you are wanting the silhouette or wanting details in the shadows. (How you meter it will make a difference in this too.)
I was using a handheld light meter and was metering for the overall scene. Expanding the dynamic range wasn't what I was trying to do in this one.
I agree that it is a matter of opinion and the original image was my opinion of how this image needed to me.
Thank you for your input.