The second go-around is better, in my opinion - there is no interesting glow on her face. As others have noted, the colour of her hair and the background are very similar in tone, and her hair therefore kinda blends into the background, which is a shame since she has a very nice head of hair. The contouring light on her looks good - we can definitely see she has curves. I'm a little put off by her looking somewhere four feet above my head (as a viewer), which makes me lose some intimacy with what should be an intimate shot.