I agree with that.
Most people buy LR3 just because it costs less than CS5. What many don't realize is they are paying for, but will rarely ever need or use as intended, Lightroom's primary function - DAM (digital asset management), and are really paying an awful lot for the main reason they got Lightroom, Lightroom's secondary function - the edit rendeing engine ACR 6.
At least with CS5 you get the same ACR 6 Lightroom has, Bridge (a feature packed image browser few seem to know how to use effectively), plus all the tools and functions of CS like layers, masking, text, vector paths, soft-proofing, the list goes on quite a ways...
Indeed.
LR3 is (for me) the most valuable tool because it combines the DAM and ACR in one app, then if I need to process the photo further than what ACR provides, I take it (from LR) into Photoshop. The two work seamlessly together and, again...for me, it's easier than using Bridge+CS5. I see the value of Bridge, I just never learned how to utilize it fully. I guess, in my mind, Bridge & LR3 are interchangeable and it boils down to personal preference. Though I could be wrong, I learn something new every day
But that's all off topic, apologies.
My default settings are:
Exposure: 0
Recovery: 0
Fill Light: 0
Blacks: 5
Brightnes: 0
Contrast: +25
Clarity: +10
Vibrance: +10
Saturation: 0
Like you said, Eric, the sliders invariably change with each photo, but the base I have above gives me a bit more "punch" as a starting point. It looks like you like your starting point to be a bit more flat and subdued...which is fine. Keith likes no starting point, again...a matter of preference.
Also, something to point out is the Camera Calibration tab at the very bottom...that effects the base photo rendering that you start with in ACR.
I have my default import develop set to Camera Standard, since it is set in my camera that way. I do this because I want the initial rendering of the photo I see in LR3 to be as close to what I see on the back of the camera, as possible. Shooting in RAW, as you probably know, allows for many different starting points from which to choose, i.e Camera Neutral, Portrait, Landscape, Standard, and "Adobe Standard", etc. I, personally, don't like the way Adobe Standard looks when rendering the initial preview...too flat...hence my choice of Camera Standard and the above base settings.
Whew...sorry for the long post lol