some landscape

[HernanG]

I want to share with you my photos. Here are some landscape. Critics welcome.

 

[mmaria]

#1 it would be more pleasing if that "wooden thing"-trunk is a bit higher because it splits the frame
#2 I think it would benefit from a bit different pp
#3 I like the most
#4 it's fine
#5 is too much for me. that's a personal preference

All above is jmo. Someone will jump and say something else.

 

[WesternGuy]

You might get more input if you posted these in the Landscape forum. Also, you will make it a lot easier for folks to review/comment on your images if you number them as you post them. It would also be nice if you gave us some location information for each image - doesn't have to be that detailed, but it would be nice to know where the pics were shot, as well as a bit about how they were shot. Knowing this information helps the reviewer to understand a bit about the image. That's all.

1. The large log cuts the image in half and generally dominates it. I would have tried to find a different vantage point.
2. This is not too bad, except the foreground portion is out of focus - maybe that is what you were going for - don't know.
3. Second best of the bunch - the sky looks a little strange - is it oversaturated? The shoreline, which acts as a pseudo-horizon is tilted to the right - it should be flat.
4. Best of the bunch. I am not sure the tree adds to the image, but that is a "personal taste" thing.
5. Not crazy about this one. It looks like one of those, overdone, clownish, HDR images that you sometimes see on web sites. You might tell us a bit about how you took this one.

HTH.

WesternGuy

 

[weags77]

I think 1 could have been a great scene from a different vantage point and I'm not a fan of the processing. Something just seems off with it.

I like 2 and the different layers but I agree that it could benefit from some more post.

Number 3 I get but am not much of a fan of the processing. There is really nothing "interesting" about it either. Could maybe use a different crop or composition.

Number 4 is a cool shot but I feel like I've seen it many times. I'm also not a fan of the placement of the tree silhouette. That said I wish I was at a place where I could see a sky like that.

Number 5 is my favorite of the bunch by far. I sense you enjoyed this shot the most. I feel it's the most interesting image but I agree the processing could use a redo. It's got a lot of potential and I think if you toned it down a bit you'd have a really nice one.

For the record I am a beginner myself so take what I say with a grain of salt. You did good overall though. Might just need some practice in post processing.